22 Private Island Rentals on VRBO – 2020

  • 4 years ago
  • 1
florida private island rental vrbo

UPDATED November 2020. Have you ever wanted to play castaway on your own private island but just couldn’t quite afford any of the private islands for sale? Well here is your solution. Why not rent a private island? Check out these 22 amazing private island rentals on VRBO.

(Note: As an Airbnb and Vrbo affiliate I earn a small commission when you book through these links at no extra cost to you.)

Be sure to also check out our latest post 10 Belize Private Island Resorts to Die For or browse our entire list of more than 130 VRBO private island rentals.

1) Little Harvest Caye, Belize

Little Harvest Caye, private island for rent in Belize © VRBO

(This island is also available on Airbnb.)

Check prices & availability


2) Strand Island, Minnesota

Strand Island, private island for rent in Minnesota, USA © VRBO

Check prices & availability


3) Norval Caye, Belize

Norval Caye Belize, overwater bungalows Belize

Private island rental in Belize! If you’re looking for overwater bungalows Belize style, then this is the VRBO private island rental for you! [Update 2019: This island is now called Little Peter Oasis] and is also available on Airbnb.

Check prices and availability


4) East Sister Rock Island, Florida

East Sister Rock Island, private island rental in Florida, USA © VRBO

(This island is also available on Airbnb.)

Check prices & availability


5) Isleta Mosqueteros, Granada, Nicaragua

Isleta Mosqueteros, private island rental in Lake Nicaragua, Granada, Nicaragua © VRBO

Check prices & availability


6) Moosehead Lake, Maine

Vrbo private island in Maine
Moosehead Lake, private island in Maine on VRBO

Check prices & availability


7) Rockwell Lighthouse, Alaska

lighthouse rental, private island, Sitka, Alaska
Rockwell lighthouse private island rental Sitka Alaska

Check prices & availability


8) Trevor Island, British Columbia, Canada

Trevor Island, private island rental in British Columbia, Canada © VRBO

Check prices & availability


9) Quiet Cove Key, Florida

Quiet Cove Key, a private island rental in the Florida Keys © VRBO

Check prices & availability


8 Florida private island rentals that will make you drool!You may also be interested in: Top 8 Florida Private Island Rentals on VRBO

or: 12 Airbnb Private Island Rentals Under $200

 


10) Whiskey Island, NY

Vrbo islands New York
Whiskey Island, NY VRBO private island rental

Check prices & availability


11) Pot Island, Connecticut

Pot Island, island for rent in the Thimble Islands, Connecticut. © VRBO

Check prices & availability


12) Watch Island, Thousand Islands, New York

Watch Island, private island rental in the Thousand Islands, New York © VRBO

Check prices & availability


13) Devil’s Elbow Cottage, South Carolina

islands Vrbo
Devil’s Elbow Cottage, private island South Carolina

Check prices & availability


14) Blackbird Island, Minnesota

Blackbird island, Minnesota VRBO private island rental
Blackbird Island, Minnesota private island rental

Check prices & availability


15) Friendly Island, Thousand Islands, New York

Friendly Island, VRBO private island rentals Thousand Islands, New York
Friendly Island, Thousand Islands, NY private island rental VRBO

Check prices & availability


16) Hattie Cay, Bahamas

Hattie Cay, Bahamas private island VRBO

Check prices & availability


17) Nautilus Island, Maine

Maine private island rental vrbo
Nautilus Island, Maine

Check prices & availability


18) Cedar Key, Florida

Vrbo island rental Florida
Cedar Key, Florida island rental Vrbo

Check prices & availability


19) Kanu Private Island, Belize

Kanu Island Belize private island rental
Kanu Island, Belize

Check prices & availability


20) Pink Pearl Island, Nicaragua

private island rental Vrbo
Pink Pearl Island rental on Vrbo, Nicaragua

Check prices & availability


21) Round Island, Indiana

Vrbo private islands
Round Island Indiana, Vrbo private island rental

Check prices & availability


22) Little Diamond Island, Maine

Maine private island Vrbo
Little Diamond Island, rent a private island in Maine

Check prices & availability


Read this next: Top 8 Florida Private Island Rentals on Vrbo and Airbnb


Join The Discussion

Compare listings

Compare